Marshall Memo 807
A Weekly Round-up of Important Ideas and Research in K-12 Education
October 14, 2019
1. Taking full advantage of the freedom that ESSA provides
2. Preventing school shootings
4. The distance between adults and today’s young people
5. The power of classroom meetings
6. The effect of teachers’ race and experience on student achievement
7. Are all students really getting it?
8. Increasing student participation in class
9. A study of states’ teacher-evaluation policies
10. Young adult books featuring mental health issues
11. Short item: Online curriculum resources
“…Our souls make us radically equal. Our brains and bodies are not equal, but our souls are… The person who is infuriating you most right now still has a soul and so is still, deep down, beautiful and redeemable… When all is said and done all souls have a common home together, a final resting place as pieces of a larger unity.”
David Brooks in “The Souls of Brown, White, and Black Folk” in The New York
Times, October 11, 2019, https://nyti.ms/2IEOUO4
“The allure of testing lies in its apparent neutrality – its democratic indifference to a student’s background and wealth. But this is not how the current system functions. Success correlates closely to socioeconomic advantages and access to test preparation.”
Jelani Cobb in “This Is a Test” in The New Yorker, September 16, 2019,
“In classrooms, labs, and libraries where student discussion is encouraged, many may be talking – but not all may be participating, Students speak less for a multitude of reasons. They may be shy, introverted, or struggling to master a new language…”
Carly Berwick (see item #8)
“As a building leader, I [am] aware that the tone of a building is set by what you allow, what you stop, what you ignore, and what you reinforce.”
Anthony Ciuffo in “Rethinking Conventions: Keeping Gender-Diverse Students Safe”
in Educational Leadership, October 2019 (Vol. 77, #2, pp. 70-75),
https://bit.ly/2VIj6xh; Ciuffo can be reached at [email protected].
“Unlearning NCLB” by Joshua Starr in Phi Delta Kappan, October 2019 (Vol. 101, #2, pp. 58-59), no e-link available
In this article in Education Week, Jillian Peterson (Hamline University/St. Paul) and James Densley (Metropolitan State University/St. Paul), both leaders of The Violence Project, say there is a $3 billion industry focused on protecting students and educators from mass shootings: reconfiguring school architecture, classroom locks, security cameras with facial recognition, safe rooms, bulletproof windows, Kevlar backpack inserts, and lockdown drills. “There is no evidence that any of this stuff works,” say Peterson and Densley. “All we do know is that the search for school safety solutions is sending districts into more debt and hurting school climate.” More than half of U.S. teens worry about a shooting in their school, even though the chance of that happening is roughly one in 614 million.
Peterson and Densley spent two years looking for a better approach. Under a grant from the National Institute of Justice, they studied the life histories of mass shooters back to 1966 and all school shootings starting with Columbine. They also interviewed incarcerated school shooters, their families, students who planned violence but changed their minds, survivors, teachers, administrators, and first responders. They combed through media and social media, suicide notes and manifestos written by perpetrators, trial transcripts, and medical records. The researchers found that although there isn’t a single profile or predictor of violence, school shooters shared these characteristics:
“Why School Shootings Happen” by Jillian Peterson and James Densley in Education Week, October 9, 2019 (Vol. 39, #8, p. 20), https://bit.ly/2IOD6sG; the authors can be reached at [email protected] and [email protected].
(Originally titled “School Safety Starts from Within”)
In this Educational Leadership article, author Thomas Armstrong advocates for mindfulness in schools as part of an overall strategy to prevent violence and deal with the stress students and staff experience in today’s world. Armstrong defines mindfulness as “attending to each present moment in time with an attitude of acceptance, openness, and curiosity.” The three key components are focus (on breathing, body sensations, or any regular activity), open monitoring (noticing internal and external experiences), and attitude (open, nonjudgmental acceptance). The goal is for people to “train their minds, regulate their emotions, control their behaviors, and cultivate healthier relationships with the people and events around them.”
Mindfulness has 1,000-year Buddhist roots and numerous modern studies have supported its efficacy for reducing stress, pain, anxiety, depression, and other physical and mental afflictions. It’s being implemented in an increasing number of schools to reduce bullying, hate speech, conflict, and violence. Armstrong has these suggestions:
• Start small. Top-down edicts for full-blown implementation are not the way to go; better to start with a group of committed educators and expand from there.
• Don’t introduce it as an add-on. Doing so will spark resistance from teachers who have been asked to take on too much in recent years. It’s strategic to fold mindfulness into existing SEL or PBIS programs.
• Keep it secular. The practice should be free of religious or spiritual trappings, emphasizing the scientific evidence of its impact.
• Try mindfulness yourself. “This ensures that you will have credibility with your students, understand their experiences, and have the tools to stay calm yourself during the ups and downs of the school day,” says Armstrong.
• Don’t expect instant results. Mindfulness works through awareness, which translates over time into being able to handle impulsivity, conflict, anger, and negative experiences.
• Have students share their experiences. This helps them process their increasing awareness and get support for their struggles.
“It’s not our imagination, kids really are different,” says former counselor and administrator Jen Cort in this article in AMLE Magazine. “Today’s youth face four constructs that adults either did not experience at all or did not experience in the same way as youth today.” Here’s her list:
• Athletics – Many kids “major in sports” as early as seven, and sometimes focus on only one sport. Often it’s, “I’m James, a soccer player,” versus “I am James, I play soccer, baseball, and like video games.” In addition to narrowing their experience and being set up for disappointment if they don’t qualify for elite teams, specialization increases the risk of overuse and traumatic injuries. Some parents get too involved, sending an unfortunate message when victories are followed by an exultant “We won the game!” but losses by, “I’m sorry you lost.”
• Devices – Smartphones are ubiquitous, says Cort, and Google is where kids find out about things that previous generations asked the adults in their lives. One boy was told by his mother that he was too young to know what pansexual meant, so he found out online. Another asked about Charlottesville and didn’t get answers, so he went to YouTube and watched the death of Heather Heyer over and over. His takeaway was that if you stand up for what you believe, you can be killed, which directly contradicted what adults had been preaching about being an upstander. Kids are quick to see the hypocrisy of adults telling them not to be on their phones all the time and doing the same thing themselves. But limit-setting is sometimes grudgingly appreciated: one boy acknowledged that his family’s rule about not having a smartphone in the bedroom overnight was good for him.
• Development – We used to think the maturation of kids’ frontal lobes (responsible for impulse control) was complete by 18, but now scientists say it’s more like the mid-to late-20s. Puberty happens around sixth grade, right? Actually it occurs between age 8 and 13 for girls and 9 and 14 for boys – and physical changes are preceded by chemical rumblings. Families celebrate early developmental milestones – moving from a tricycle to a two-wheeler – but are reticent when it comes to preparing their kids for adolescence. “Parents and teachers serve students well,” says Cort, “by letting them know as young as second grade that just as they grew from babies to second graders, they will also grow from second graders to teenagers. Just as when they were babies, adults are present to support them through these changes.”
• Diversity – Let’s assume that people don’t remember most events that occurred before they were four. That means today’s:
- 19-year-olds don’t remember a time before smartphones and 9/11 (and the subsequent surge of Islamophobia).
In this article in Middle School Journal, Jamie Silverman and Molly Mee (Towson University) describe middle-school students with serious concerns:
In this article in Educational Researcher, Katie Vinopal (The Ohio State University) and Stephen Holt (University at Albany, SUNY) report the results of their study on the impact of teachers’ race and level of experience on student achievement. “A growing body of research has documented the important benefits teachers of color bring to students of color,” say Vinopal and Holt, “including higher expectations.” Studies have also found that teachers become more effective with more years of classroom experience. Here’s what the researchers found about the interaction of these two variables:
“Rookie Mistakes: The Interplay of Teacher Experience and Racial Representation” by Katie Vinopal and Stephen Holt in Educational Researcher, October 2019 (Vol. 48, #7, pp. 421-437), https://bit.ly/35veoHw; the authors can be reached at [email protected] and [email protected].
In this Edutopia article, Pérsida and Bill Himmele (Millersville University) say teachers often check for whole-class understanding by asking, Who can tell me…? or Does anyone know…? This approach has three important design flaws: (a) only a few students raise their hands and reap the academic and confidence-building benefits of being actively engaged in the discussion, while most classmates sit passively; (b) teachers tend to believe the eager beavers’ answers are representative of the learning of all students; and (c) “those students who are most likely to need help,” say the authors, “who have deep misunderstandings, or who are in the process of learning English, are the ones who are unintentionally left out of the conversation.” They suggest three better ways to check for understanding and engage all students:
• Chalkboard splash – The teacher poses a well-framed question that captures the big ideas of what’s being taught (for example, What are some challenges that you could see developing within societies that embrace capitalism?). Students are asked to write their responses in their notebooks or on a separate sheet of paper in 15 words or less. Students then get up and write their responses on the board. This gets every student thinking, gets them all out of their seats, makes a diversity of ideas visible to everyone, gives the teacher a good idea of how well the lesson is sinking in, and often leads to good follow-up.
• Appointment agendas – Each student gets a grid https://edut.to/2B9JYwv and circulates among classmates making mutual “appointments” for each of the hypothetical time-slots (8:00 a.m., 9:00 a.m., etc.). When the teacher poses a thought-provoking question, students are asked to confer with their partner for a particular time-slot (10:00 a.m., for example – it doesn’t have to correspond to the actual time), and students get up, find their appointment buddy, and discuss the question. This produces purposeful movement around the class, lots of interaction, and sets up an all-class discussion and closure.
• Pause, star, rank – After a chunk of content has been presented (for example, a two-week unit on the American Revolution), students look over their notes, put a star by each concept they believe is important to remember, and then rank-order their top three starred choices. Then students get up, do a chalkboard splash with their top-ranked concept, and discuss it with a designated Appointment Agenda classmate.
In this National Council on Teacher Quality article, Nicole Gerber comments on a 2019 NCTQ study, “Teacher and Principal Evaluation Policy.” Some key findings:
Curriculum resources – The Partnership https://www.thepartnership-ny.org in upstate New York provides free resources, tools, and professional development geared to Common Core ELA and math standards.
© Copyright 2019 Marshall Memo LLC
About the Marshall Memo
Mission and focus:
This weekly memo is designed to keep principals, teachers, superintendents, and other educators very well-informed on current research and effective practices in K-12 education. Kim Marshall, drawing on 50 years’ experience as a teacher, principal, central office administrator, writer, and consultant lightens the load of busy educators by serving as their “designated reader.”
To produce the Marshall Memo, Kim subscribes to 60 carefully-chosen publications (see list to the right), sifts through more than a hundred articles each week, and selects 5-10 that have the greatest potential to improve teaching, leadership, and learning. He then writes a brief summary of each article, pulls out several striking quotes, provides e-links to full articles when available, and e-mails the Memo to subscribers every Monday evening (with occasional breaks; there are 50 issues a year). Every week there’s a podcast and HTML version as well.
Individual subscriptions are $50 for a year. Rates decline steeply for multiple readers within the same organization. See the website for these rates and how to pay by check, credit card, or purchase order.
Website:
If you go to http://www.marshallmemo.com you will find detailed information on:
• How to subscribe or renew
• A detailed rationale for the Marshall Memo
• Publications (with a count of articles from each)
• Article selection criteria
• Topics (with a running count of articles)
• Headlines for all issues
• Reader opinions
• About Kim Marshall (bio, writings, consulting)
• A free sample issue
Subscribers have access to the Members’ Area of the website, which has:
• The current issue (in Word and PDF)
• All back issues (Word and PDF) and podcasts
• An easily searchable archive of all articles so far
• The “classic” articles from all 14+ years
Core list of publications covered
Those read this week are underlined.
All Things PLC
American Educational Research Journal
American Educator
American Journal of Education
AMLE Magazine
ASCA School Counselor
District Management Journal
Ed. Magazine
Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis
Educational Horizons
Educational Leadership
Elementary School Journal
English Journal
Essential Teacher
Exceptional Children
Go Teach
Harvard Business Review
Harvard Educational Review
Independent School
Journal of Adolescent and Adult Literacy
Journal of Education for Students Placed At Risk (JESPAR)
Kappa Delta Pi Record
Knowledge Quest
Language Arts
Literacy Today (formerly Reading Today)
Mathematics Teacher
Middle School Journal
Peabody Journal of Education
Phi Delta Kappan
Principal
Principal Leadership
Reading Research Quarterly
Responsive Classroom Newsletter
Rethinking Schools
Review of Educational Research
School Administrator
School Library Journal
Social Education
Social Studies and the Young Learner
Teaching Children Mathematics
Teaching Exceptional Children
The Atlantic
The Chronicle of Higher Education
The Journal of the Learning Sciences
The Language Educator
The Learning Professional (formerly Journal of Staff Development)
The Reading Teacher
Theory Into Practice
Time Magazine